NASG Special Projects

There have been a number of special NASG-sponsored projects produced over the years. This page captures that information. The primary source for this information were the reports listed in the NASG Dispatch issues, and some personal correspondence.

Contact person: webmaster

(this page is still a work-in-progress, so check back from time to time; this note will be removed when the webmaster has collected all the info he could find)

History

Officially, the program was started by Dick Cataldi in 1986, taken over by Don DeWitt in 1987, and finally Alan Evans ran it from 1989 through 2015 as the special projects chairman. In 2015 Alan retired, and the NASG BOT found that the program had pretty much run its course.

The program has had several names over the years, such as "Brass Car Committee" (1983), "Freight Car Committee" (1996), and "Special Projects Committee". Some projects took more than one year to complete, some failed, and some years had more than one product released.

These projects were a delicate issue, because the NASG is not intended to be a manufacturer, and it doesn't want to appear to be a competitor to the existing S-scale manufacturers. Also, the NASG does not want to favor one manufacturer over another, so the organization worked closely with a number of manufacturers and took bids on certain projects.

Not Covered Here

American Flyer Commemorative Cars: the NASG has been sponsoring this project since 1981, and that is a separate program from the ones covered on this page.

NASG Convention Cars: the annual NASG Convention cars are sponsored by the club or individuals who organize and sponsor that particular Convention. However, the NASG may elect to offer some seed money up-front for those projects, with the Convention organizers paying the NASG back when the Convention completes.

1984


© Chuck West; used by permission

The "Brass Car Committee" commissioned Overland Models to produce two sets of brass hopper cars. The committee consisted of Don Thompson, Jim Kindraka, and Michael Ferraro (NASG treasurer at the time). Also involved were NASG president Rollie Mercier and, then Overland Models' employee, Jettie Padgett (who later started SouthWind Models).

The models were the American Car & Foundry's Type II and Type III two-bay, rib-sided, covered hoppers. They were imported by Overland Models, and built in Korea by Ajin Precision Ltd. The cars sold for $85 each for NASG members and $95 for non-NASG members (price was increased by $5 in May of 1984). The models arrived unpainted, as was customary for projects of this type back then. The significance of these models was that they came with wheels that were set to the then-new (and correct) NASG gauge, which at the time was different from the NMRA gauge for S-scale standard-gauge models.

The photo above is of Jim Kindraka's model, painted and lettered for the NYC. This is the later "Phase III" version, which can be identified by the closed-off center section (compare it against the photo below).


© Chuck West; used by permission

The photo on the right is of Jim's model, painted and lettered for the Monon. This is the earlier "Phase II" version, which can be identified by the open center section.

Jim recalls the effort in his article in the July 2015 issue of the NASG's Dispatch magazine on page 15. Jim makes it clear that the NASG did not subsidize the project; funding came from deposits NASG members made for the project. The profits from the sales were given to the NASG.

1986

The "Brass Car Committee" again commissioned Overland Models to produce five sets of brass tank cars (see the 1984 entry above for more info about the committee itself). The decision to go with the tank cars was based on the results received from the survey included with the 1984 cars (they were the #1 and #2 voted-for entries).

The models were the American Car & Foundry's 10,000-gallon 1-, 2-, and 3-dome tank cars. They were imported by Overland Models, and built in Korea by Ajin Precision Ltd. The models arrived unpainted, and were available with scale wheels in T-section Bettendorf trucks or with AF wheels in Ace Bettendorf trucks. They sold for $88 each at pre-order prices, later increased to $98.

Some additional information was covered in Jim Kindraka's article in the July 2015 issue of the NASG's Dispatch magazine on page 16. The profits from the sales were given to the NASG. Below is a listing of the models.


© Tom Henderson; used by permission

This is the 1-dome, non-insulated, low-pressure version.


© Jim Kindraka; used by permission

This is the 1-dome, insulated, low-pressure version.


© Bill Lane; used by permission

The 1-dome, insulated, high-pressure version.


© Bill Lane; used by permission

The 2-dome, non-insulated, low-pressure version.


© Edwin Kirstatter; used by permission

The 3-dome, non-insulated, low-pressure version.

1991


© Bill Winans; used by permission

The effort to produce a Milwaukee Road horizontal-ribbed, 40-foot, brass box car was started in 1987. The models eventually materialized in 1991 as part of a River Raisin Models project to make three versions of the Milwaukee ribbed-side box cars. River Raisin made the entire run of the 40' version with 6' Superior doors available to the NASG as an exclusive for its members. The model cost $152.95, which included shipping.

The cars were manufactured by Ajin Precision Ltd of Korea and imported through Overland Models. River Raisin Models separately sold a 40' version with 6' Youngstown doors, as well as a 50-foot double Superior door version, but these were not part of the NASG project. All three versions of the models were imported in either a shiny brass or factory-painted but not lettered finish, as shown here. Lettering was available from C-D-S Dry Transfers.

1997


© Bob Werre; used by permission

S-Helper Service was commissioned to produce 300 models of their 53-foot PRR flat car, equipped with an Ertl road grader as the load (SHS #00176). The car cost $45, and included both scale and hi-rail wheels and couplers.

The second car that was available in 1997 was the Downs Model Railroad Co.'s 23,000-gallon modern tank car. It was painted black and available with three different road numbers. On one side of the car was the "Trusweet" logo, which is a white background with green and yellow letters, while on the other side are the words "Trusweet" and "Amaizo". The models were available with either scale or hi-rail wheels and couplers, and cost $40 ($1.50 extra for operating hi-rail couplers).

We are looking for a photo of this car (contact the webmaster).

1998

S-Helper Service was commissioned to produce another 300 models of their 53-foot flat car, this time equipped with an Ertl John Deere excavator load and lettered for the Union Pacific. The car included both scale and hi-rail wheels and couplers, and cost $50. We are looking for a photo of this car with the Ertl excavator load (contact the webmaster).

1999

The NASG commissioned Pacific Rail Shops to produce, for the first time in these special projects, a kit of a 50-foot Union Pacific box car. Because this was a kit, sales were slow. Most projects sold out within the year they were made available, but these were still not sold out in 2001.

We are looking for a photo of this car (contact the webmaster).

2000


(pre-production, evaluation model as shown in the Dispatch)

In July 1999 the NASG BOT commissioned 200 brass cars from SouthWind Models. These were to be the TTUX Front Runner intermodal spine cars, available only with scale wheels as hi-rail wheels would interfere with their operation. Two versions were to be produced, with five road numbers each. The photo shows a pre-production model used for testing the rigid wheels to handle model curves.

By December 2000 the pilot model was reviewed by several prototype experts who offered their suggestions for improving and correcting the model before the final production was to be started. Unfortunately, word leaked out on various discussion forums about the minor issues with the model, which people mis-interpreted as being a critical review of the final model, and so pre-orders stopped immediately. The pilot model was enhanced by an expert modeler before being returned to the manufacturer.

In April 2001 it was announced that SouthWind Models canceled the project. It was not due to the low pre-orders, but rather that the Korean builder who built the pilot model disappeared, taking with him the car and all of the plans and drawings. Jettie Padgett, owner of SouthWind Models, even flew to Korea to go look for this person, but he never found him. It was estimated that he lost about $5,000 because of this. All NASG members who pre-ordered the car received their deposits back.

2002


© Ken Garber; used by permission

It is a relatively small, modern (post-1960) building measuring 16'x28'. It was based on the BNSF mainline structure found near Kings Park, California, but it is generic enough to be used just about anywhere. The model sold for $20, and they were already shipping by the time of the 2002 NASG Convention. There are product reviews of it in the December 2002 (page 12) and February 2004 (page 8) issues of the NASG's Dispatch magazine, both providing additional photographs. At the 2008 NASG Convention's BOT meeting, the announcement was made that Des Plaines Hobbies bought the remaining kits and its tooling.

2004


NYC-style 10-1-2 (American Models stock photo)

The NASG commissioned American Models to produce two configurations of Pullman heavyweight, 80', sleeper passenger cars in five different body colors. One configuration was the 10-section, 1-drawing room, 2-compartment (10-1-2) sleeper car, shown here on the right.


NYC-style 12-1 (American Models stock photo)

The other car was a 12-section, 1-drawing room (12-1) car, shown on the right. The cars arrived painted, but not lettered. Custom decals, appropriate for the chosen body color, were included. The body colors included the NYC-style two-tone gray, which is shown in these first two photos. Other railroads that used cars with this paint scheme were: B&M, B&O, C&O, FEC, GM&O, 1C, MP, NKP, SAL, and SR.


Undecorated 10-1-2 (American Models stock photo)

Also included in this project were the Pullman green undecorated cars. These models came with a clear roof.


Pullman 10-1-2 (American Models stock photo)

Another set of cars were painted Pullman green, but these came with black roofs for Pullman-owned/operated cars.


CNR 10-1-2, corrected (American Models stock photo)

Another body color was the Canadian National Railways black & green body with yellow stripes. The initial batch of CNR cars were painted with the incorrect color. A remediation kit was made available to those who had purchased the cars. Members could also send the models back for professional repainting service. The cars that hadn't sold yet were repainted before being sold. Andy Malette was the one who did the professional repainting work.


PRR-style 10-1-2 (American Models stock photo)

Also available was the PRR-style Tuscan red.

The project was such a great success that American Models released a matching cafe car for each of the body colors shortly after these were released. After the initial commission sold out, American Models offered these cars as part of their regular product line, and they are still available today.

2006


© Peter Vanvliet; used by permission

In conjunction with Showcase Miniatures, the NASG presented the "Sunkist Packing Shed" kit. It was a shallow-relief kit. The company had produced this kit in HO-scale. The NASG co-sponsored 50 units of the kit in S-scale so that the company's minimum order could be met. By the August 2006 issue of the Dispatch, the kits were sold out. However, the company continued to carry the kit in S-scale for a number of years. Later, the company stopped producing S-scale kits, and subsequently changed ownership in 2015. Gerry Evans worked hard behind-the-scenes to make this project come to fruition.


(Palace Car Co stock photo)

Also released in 2006 was a special run of the Palace Car Co.'s passenger sleeper car seats (far right, center of photo) for the American Models passenger cars released in 2004. However, they were sold out within a matter of days after their announcement, so the company started re-stocking them and making them available directly, and they are still available today.

2007


© Dick Karnes; used by permission

The passenger car seats manufactured by Palace Car Co. were such a success that the NASG teamed up with them again to produce a set for a full interior. Two versions of these beautiful kits include all seats, seat arm rests, partitions, floor material, and instructions for 12-1 and 10-1-2 heavyweight Pullman cars (for the ones produced by American Models in 2004). The full set can be seen in the photo above for the 2006 entry, and these are still available today. Dick Karnes wrote a more detailed article about this project in the December 2007 issue of the Dispatch.

2009


(final production model as shown in the Dispatch)

Kermit's Kleaning Kemicals was a modular brick building kit. The plan was to develop a system of brick building wall components, similar to what the company Design Preservation Models offers in N-, HO-, and O-scale. The building, when built as intended, has a footprint of 8"x12", and stands 8" tall. It sold for $99.95.

The project was started in 2004 by Jerry Porter's Innovative Model Works and the NASG. In late 2006, banta modelworks was assigned the project. The kit was finally released at the 2009 NASG Convention after much behind-the-scenes work by Gerry Evans. In 2010 banta modelworks announced that it was leaving S-scale, so that eliminated the continuation of these components. The project had a good premise, but it was beset with behind-the-scenes issues and set-backs. Rusty Westermeier wrote a less-than-favorable article about his constructing one of these kits in the October 2010 issue of the S Gaugian magazine.

2013


© Bill Winans; used by permission

The NASG commissioned American Models to produce heavyweight baggage cars as a separate item. The car was previously only available as part of the five-car PRR passenger car set that American Models has. The cars arrived painted Pullman-green, but were undecorated. They had a black roof and underbody. They were available with either 4-wheeled or 6-wheeled trucks, with the 4-wheeled ones being in limited supply. By default, all wheels were "scale" wheels, but hi-rail versions were available. The photo shows Kadee couplers installed, but those were not provided with the model.

Copyright © 2018 NASG, Inc.; all rights reserved